Why “Exercise as Punishment” Is a Fear-Based Coaching Failure and what it really teaches young athletes

We’ve all seen it—or done it.The team’s not clicking. Mistakes are piling up.Coach yells, “On the line!”Now the players are running sprints instead of learning how to fix the breakdown.

It might feel like it’s the right action. For many of us who grew up in sport, this was the way. But here’s the truth: using exercise as punishment is fear-based coaching. And the more we learn about the developing brain—especially in today’s generation—the more we understand just how ineffective and potentially damaging that approach really is.

 The Science Is Clear: Fear Doesn’t Build Learning

A recent article from The Conversation dives into this: fear shuts down the parts of the brain responsible for reflection, reasoning, and creativity. Instead, it fires up the survival brain—fight, flight, or freeze. That means a player may appear more focused after being punished, but they’re not processing information. They’re avoiding threats.

And here's the thing: that visible effort spike? It’s not improvement—it’s compliance. And it fades fast.

Generational Shift: Gen X Coaching Gen Alpha

Let’s be honest. A lot of us were coached in the "suck it up and run" era. But today’s players aren't wired the same way. And that’s not a weakness—it’s neuroscience.

Gen Alpha (kids born ~2010 and onward) are developing in a radically different world than Gen X did:

• More digital stimulation

• Higher sensitivity to feedback

• Greater mental health awareness

• Increased demand for autonomy, not authority

  
  

Research shows the adolescent brain today is even more responsive to relational safety, guided discovery, and emotional validation than previous generations. That means fear-based tactics are not just outdated—they’re counterproductive.

What Safe Sport and People Like Alison Forsyth Are Telling Us

Alison Forsyth, a former Olympian and Safe Sport advocate, pushes us to examine how our environments—intentionally or not—reinforce power dynamics that make athletes feel powerless. Her message? Coaching rooted in fear, shame, or threat creates long-term harm. And we often don't see the impact until it’s too late.

This isn’t just about avoiding abuse. It’s about designing spaces where kids feel safe enough to grow—mentally, physically, socially, and emotionally.

Accountability ≠ Punishment

Here’s a really important distinction:

• Accountability means players are held to standards, take ownership, and face natural consequences. 

• Punishment—especially physical punishment—is reactive, fear-based, and often disconnected from the learning goal.

• 
  

We can absolutely hold kids accountable. But it has to be educational, proportionate, and connected to growth—not humiliation or exhaustion.

 A Real Example: Coach vs. Player Experience

Coach (Gen X):“They weren’t switched on, so I made them run. They got the message and locked in after that.”

Player (Gen Alpha, U13):“I felt embarrassed. I didn’t understand what I was supposed to do better—I just didn’t want to be the one who messed up again. I stayed quiet and tried not to be noticed.”

This isn’t learning. It’s behavioral compliance driven by fear, not understanding. Long term? That kills creativity, confidence, and connection to the sport.

What Works Better: The Grumpy Soccer Way

At GrumpySoccer.ca, we’re all about tough love—but never fear-based coaching. There’s a better way:

• Teach through the mistake: “Here’s what went wrong—let’s try again.”

• Build pressure with purpose: Game scenarios, score-based challenges, timed tasks.

• Create reflection moments: Have players lead debriefs or ask questions.

• Celebrate effort and improvement: Especially when it’s not perfect.

  
  

Effort driven by motivation sticks. Effort driven by fear? It fades—and often leaves a scar.

 For Coaches to Reflect On

• Are we coaching the way we were coached—or the way these kids need to be coached?

• Do our actions build trust—or control?

• Are we measuring success by compliance—or by development?

  
  

Final Thought

Exercise as punishment might look effective in the short term—but it’s an illusion. It teaches kids to fear mistakes, not to solve them. It teaches them to stay quiet, not to think critically. And it teaches them that their effort is only valuable when it’s attached to a consequence.

We owe it to the next generation to do better. Let’s build spaces that teach accountability, build trust, and actually help players grow—not just survive the session.